By Drew Gurley, EVP of Growth, Senior Market Advisors
If a client is better off keeping the coverage they already have, tell them. Say it plainly, explain why, and be willing to leave the appointment without an application.
That’s the standard at Senior Market Advisors.
It counts when you’re one application short of your goal, you’ve already spent an hour at the kitchen table, and you know the client would sign if you asked. You’ll go home and move on to the next appointment.
They’ll live with the coverage decision you helped them make.
What Trust Looks Like in Medicare
In 2026, the average Medicare beneficiary had 39 Medicare Advantage plans available to them. In J.D. Power’s 2026 study, only 43% of Medicare Advantage members agreed that their plan was a trusted partner in their health and wellness.
I’ve enrolled countless people in Medicare plans and trained thousands of agents. In my experience, most clients want answers to four questions.
- Can I keep my doctor?
- What will my prescriptions cost?
- What happens if I get really sick?
- Can I rely on the agent I’m talking to?
That fourth question comes up whether the client says it out loud or not.
They’re deciding whether they can trust you with their information, whether you understand what matters to them, and whether you’ll pick up the phone after they enroll.
Let’s say a client calls about a dental benefit she saw advertised. Ten minutes into the appointment, you learn she sees a cardiologist every three months and takes a prescription she can barely afford. Now you know where to spend your time. Verify the cardiologist at the office she actually visits. Check what she’d pay for the prescription at the pharmacy she uses. Show her what she’d gain and what she’d give up.
Then explain where the dental benefit fits into that decision.
Make It Easy for Clients to Verify Who You Are
Agent verification is more important than ever!
If I called your parents about their Medicare coverage tomorrow, could they look me up, confirm I’m licensed and call me back at a number they found on their own? Every agent should be able to answer yes to that question.
AI makes it easier to create a fake profile or mimic someone’s voice. That makes it more important for beneficiaries to have a way to verify who they’re dealing with before sharing a Medicare number, a medication list or other personal information.
You have the choice to give them that option up front!
- Give clients your full name as it appears on your license. Show them where to look up your license through their state insurance department.
- Keep your public information current. Your agency name and business phone number should match across your agency website, directory listings and public profiles. Update them when something changes.
- Invite clients to check a verified profile. Tell them they’re welcome to look you up and call back using the number published on your agency’s website. Give them time to do it.
I would get a verified agent profile on MedicarePlanFinder.com where we run monthly checks with a third party to constantly provide consumers confidence they can work with verified agents.
We are committed to leading the industry on public agent verification through our partnership with Agent Review. As EVP of Growth, I want our agency partners to make this part of onboarding and keep it current as their teams grow. An agency owner should know who’s responsible for updating a profile when an agent joins, leaves or changes their contact information. A beneficiary should be able to find the right person without making three calls. SMA and Agent Review’s national verification initiative
Search your own name the way a client would. If they can’t verify your license or find the right number to call, fix it.
What Our Partners Should Expect From SMA
I’m responsible for growth at SMA. We set sales goals, track production and celebrate when our partners deliver. If we’re behind, that’s our problem to solve. A beneficiary deserves the same recommendation on the last day of the Annual Enrollment Period that they’d get on the first.
SMA is a distribution services business. Our job is to help agency owners grow their businesses and give their agents the support to do good work at every step. For me, best-in-class support has to show up when the work gets hard.
- Before the appointment, an agent should know how to run a coverage review, where to get marketing materials reviewed and how to make their credentials easy to verify.
- During the appointment, an agent should know where to turn when plan information conflicts or a compliance question comes up.
- After enrollment, an agency should know who can help when an application stalls, coverage starts on the wrong date or a client calls because something they expected to be covered isn’t.
I want to know how many applications we submitted. I also want to know how many took effect, where clients needed help and what issues keep coming back. If the same problem keeps turning up across an agency, find out where it starts and fix it.
At our core, that’s part of the work our partners should expect us to help with.
Seven Commitments for Every Medicare Appointment
- Honor the client’s time. Show up when you said you would, and come prepared to discuss what the client asked about. Crush your first impression!
- Be clear about who you are. Explain your role, which plans you represent and how the client can verify your credentials. Give the required disclosures where they apply and offer the chance for them to take a look at your verified profile.
- Find out what the client wants to protect. Ask what’s working, what’s causing problems and what they’d change if they could change one thing.
- Give the client time to decide. If a lower premium means giving up a specialist, walk through what that would mean for their care and their budget. Give them time to ask questions and weigh it.
- Explain the options that fit. Compare the relevant plans you represent, explain the limits of what you offer and show the client where to review the full range of options. Include keeping their current coverage when it makes sense.
- Verify the details that could change the decision. Check the specific plan and plan year. Verify the providers and prescriptions the client relies on, explain what happens to their current coverage and show what they could pay when they use the plan. If a material detail is unclear, get the answer before you recommend a change.
- Make the recommendation you can stand behind. Explain it in words the client could repeat to a spouse or adult child. Give them a way to reach you afterward, whether they enroll or keep what they have.
Let’s Talk About How Your Agency Grows
Bring us a problem that keeps coming up during AEP. It could be an enrollment issue your agents spend too much time chasing, a gap in how new agents are trained or something as basic as clients struggling to verify who called them. Tell us where the work gets stuck. We’ll talk through what it would take to fix it for your team and the beneficiaries they serve. Talk with the SMA growth team